The Supreme Court has held that land on a working quayside was properly registered as a town or village green (TVG).
Registration did not, on the facts of the case, criminalise or otherwise prevent the landowner from using the land for pre-existing commercial purposes, provided those purposes remained compatible with the recreational rights protected by the TVG registration (TW Logistics Ltd v Essex CC and another  UKSC 4).
The quayside had been used concurrently for many years for both the landowner’s commercial activities (passage of vehicles and storage of cargo) and local inhabitants’ general recreation (dog walking and stopping to chat on the quayside).
In 2010, part of the quayside was registered as a TVG following an application made by a local resident. The application was accepted on the basis that it met the statutory criteria: the quayside had been used “as of right” for lawful sports and pastimes by significant numbers of local inhabitants for the preceding 20 years.
The landowner unsuccessfully challenged the registration in the High Court, the Court finding that the commercial and recreational uses had co-existed for many years and could continue to be compatible notwithstanding the TVG registration. The landowner’s appeal to the Court of Appeal also failed.
The issue for the Supreme Court was whether the quayside had been validly registered as a TVG.
The landowner appealed on three separate grounds:
Due to the conclusion reached on Ground 2, the Court declined to consider this point.
The Court held that they were not. Various potential offences were considered including interrupting locals’ use of a TVG for recreational purposes, driving a motor vehicle on a TVG without lawful authority, and health and safety offences. In each case the Court concluded the landowner would have lawful authority to undertake the activities in question, meaning no offence would be committed.
The Court outlined the principle of “give and take”, whereby locals must exercise their rights over a TVG in a fair and reasonable way, so as to respect the concurrent reasonable and established use by the landowner. The landowner cannot be prevented from undertaking activities of the same general quality and at the same general level as before the TVG registration. It may even carry out new and different activities than before, but only where those expanded activities do not interfere with the locals’ rights for recreation.
Use “as of right” is one of the necessary requirements for a valid TVG registration. The Court reiterated that this requires use of land by the locals in a way which would suggest to a reasonable landowner that those locals believed that they were exercising a right in doing so. That the locals may have moved out of the way of the landowner’s commercial activities at times did not prevent their use being as of right.
The decision is interesting in the way it reconciles a landowner’s legitimate commercial uses with locals’ recreational rights as protected by a TVG registration. It is also a reminder to landowners of the risks of registration. While a landowner is able to continue with its prior uses of the land, TVG registration will prevent expansion of or a change in activities on the land which would interfere with the protected recreational rights. This can make development very difficult or even impossible. Landowners need to be wary of turning a blind eye to activities on their land that could lead to an application for registration being made.
This case illustrates that applications for registration of land as a TVG often turn on their facts. Use “as of right” will require a use which is without secrecy, force or permission. Whether that is established or not is a question of fact in each particular case. Equally, whether the landowner’s pre-existing activities were criminalised by a TVG registration fell to be determined by examining the activities in this case.
It is perhaps disappointing that the Court declined to consider the general principle of whether TVG registration is barred if it would criminalise the landowner’s prior activities. This question will have to await a future decision and this leaves an element of uncertainty for both landowners and local inhabitants where land subject to a TVG registration is also used for commercial purposes.
This publication is intended for general guidance and represents our understanding of the relevant law and practice as at February 2021. Specific advice should be sought for specific cases. For more information see our terms & conditions.
No mandatory planning refusal for out-of-town retail and leisure...Read more
Government proposes new residential PD right and public services...Read more
Addressing London's housing crisis with L&QRead more
TLT supports Low Carbon develop UK's largest community-owned solar...Read more
Planning reforms 2020Read more
Evolving citiesRead more
Developer suffers substantial losses in 'cynical' breach of...Read more
Interpretation of planning conditionsRead more
The impact of flexible working on our towns and citiesRead more
Helping you navigate your business through the risks and opportunities that Brexit will bring.Read more
The way people shop is constantly evolving, from the growth of online and the changing use of stores...Read more
The widespread disruption and closure of businesses caused by the Covid-19 pandemic and the subsequent national and local lockdowns has brought into sharp focus the question of available insurance cover for losses under...Read more
Watch our video series for information on the legal issues that are affecting the real estate sector. Each...Read more
The pandemic has had a deep and long-lasting effect on the leisure, food & drink sector, forcing operators to embrace new ways of attracting and servicing customers.Read more
The pandemic has forced the majority of the workforce into a world of remote working. As a result, our cities are evolving.Read more
Our countdown to Brexit and beyond podcast series looks at the impact for businesses on both sides of the pond of any free trade agreement between the UK and Europe and the UK and the US. ThisRead more
There's a growing demand for retailers to do more to attract the Purple Pound – the collective spending power of disabled shoppers, estimated to be worth around £274bn. We look at the opportunities, the legal issues and...Read more
Green finance is gaining speed, driven by global climate change pressures and the recognition of the vital role which sustainability plays in a resilient financial services sector.Read more