The Lords Justices in the Court of Appeal have handed down a very helpful judgment concerning the interpretation of planning conditions.
In DB Symmetry Limited v Swindon Borough Council 2020 the court was asked to consider what was meant by the following condition attached to a planning permission granted for a substantial housing estate:
“The proposed access roads, including turning spaces and all other areas that serve a necessary highway purpose, shall be constructed in such a manner as to ensure that each unit is served by fully functional highway, the hard surfaces of which are constructed to at least basecourse level prior to occupation and bringing into use”
The developer (as Appellant before the Court) argued it meant that the estate roads serving their development did not have to be adopted, and that the purpose of the condition was to regulate the physical attributes of those estate roads.
The Council (defending their successful high court decision) believed it required that the roads be dedicated by the developer as public highways.
The dispute eventually came before the court via the following route. The developer had applied to the Council for a certificate of lawfulness, asking the Council to confirm its interpretation of the condition, that the estate roads need not be adopted. The Council refused that application and the developer appealed to the Secretary of State. The Inspector at the appeal sided with the developer and the Council successfully challenged the Inspector’s decision in the high court. It is that judgment that was appealed to the Court of Appeal.
The Court of Appeal sided with the Inspector’s interpretation of the condition, confirming that a planning condition cannot lawfully require land to be dedication as public highway without compensation. A condition such as that tries to impose a dedication requirement on a private individual, and for that reason it is invalid and unenforceable. This flows from the long established principle that a condition may not destroy private proprietary rights such as would occur were a person forced through a condition to dedicate their land a public highway.
If in the determination of a planning condition a Council concludes that a new development necessitates the creation of public highway then the appropriate mechanism for securing this is through a section 106 planning obligation and/or a section 38 highways agreement. There is no place for the dedication of roads through conditions.
In reaching this conclusion the court restated the objective tests to be applied in the interpretation of a planning condition.
The reliance on the validation principle is interesting in that it derives from contract law interpretation and proceeds on the premise that the parties intended the contract to be valid. This is despite planning conditions differing from contracts in that they are imposed by the Council, rather negotiated in the sense that a contract is.
A final point of caution to remember when embarking on a challenge to a condition. If, despite the validation principle, the court cannot find a lawful interpretation of a condition it will sever that condition from the permission which might cause the permission itself to be quashed. Such an outcome may not be the one the parties are hoping for.
This publication is intended for general guidance and represents our understanding of the relevant law and practice as at October 2020. Specific advice should be sought for specific cases. For more information see our terms & conditions.
TLT supports Network Homes with affordable housing acquisitionRead more
Court of Appeal upholds planning refusal for sustainable development...Read more
Permitted development right conversion to dwellinghouses refusedRead more
Registration of working quayside as TVG did not criminalise...Read more
No mandatory planning refusal for out-of-town retail and leisure...Read more
Government proposes new residential PD right and public services...Read more
Addressing London's housing crisis with L&QRead more
TLT supports Low Carbon develop UK's largest community-owned solar...Read more
Planning reforms 2020Read more
Helping you navigate your business through the risks and opportunities that Brexit will bring.Read more
The way people shop is constantly evolving, from the growth of online and the changing use of stores...Read more
The widespread disruption and closure of businesses caused by the Covid-19 pandemic and the subsequent national and local lockdowns has brought into sharp focus the question of available insurance cover for losses under...Read more
Watch our video series for information on the legal issues that are affecting the real estate sector. Each...Read more
The pandemic has had a deep and long-lasting effect on the leisure, food & drink sector, forcing operators to embrace new ways of attracting and servicing customers.Read more
The pandemic has forced the majority of the workforce into a world of remote working. As a result, our cities are evolving.Read more
Our countdown to Brexit and beyond podcast series looks at the impact for businesses on both sides of the pond of any free trade agreement between the UK and Europe and the UK and the US. ThisRead more
There's a growing demand for retailers to do more to attract the Purple Pound – the collective spending power of disabled shoppers, estimated to be worth around £274bn. We look at the opportunities, the legal issues and...Read more
Green finance is gaining speed, driven by global climate change pressures and the recognition of the vital role which sustainability plays in a resilient financial services sector.Read more