The High Court has now handed down judgment in the eagerly awaited test case brought by the Financial Conduct Authority (‘FCA’) against 8 insurers to determine whether policyholders can make business interruption (BI) claims for losses arising from disruption and closure of their businesses caused by Covid-19.
In a highly significant judgment, the Court found in favour of the policyholders on the majority of the claims, which involved consideration by the Court of 21 sample policy wordings.
The ruling lends a major victory to policyholders and the thousands of businesses across the country who saw their trading interrupted by Covid-19. The FCA has said that “Insurers should reflect on the clarity provided here and, irrespective of any possible appeals, consider the steps they can take now to progress claims of the type that the judgment says should be paid.” It remains to be seen what approach is now adopted by insurers.
In an unprecedented step, the recent claim was brought by the FCA on behalf of policyholders who were denied cover under their BI policies for losses resulting from the disruption caused by Covid-19.
The insurers who are involved in the FCA test case were:
The High Court judgment handed down yesterday will be legally binding on those insurers subject to any appeal. It will also provide persuasive guidance for the interpretation of similar BI policy wordings.
It will, however, take some time for the insurance industry and affected policyholders to digest the complex and lengthy judgment which runs to a total of 162 pages. Nevertheless, it is clear that insurance pay-outs are triggered under certain “no damage” clauses that cover disease and/or denial of access to business premises and that any such pay-outs should put businesses in the position that they would have been in had Covid-19 not occurred.
As the Court looked at a representative sample of policies, each policy needs to be viewed in the light of the judgment to determine whether the insured is covered. If cover is accepted in principle, the insured will also have to establish what is payable.
The parties have agreed that they will seek to have any appeal heard on an expedited basis and this includes the possibility of any appeal being ‘leapfrogged’ to the Supreme Court. This could take matters into the new year but the FCA have said that this should not preclude policyholders seeking to settle before the outcome of any appeal is known.
If your business has a BI policy, and in the light of the FCA judgment, you should prudently consider the following questions:
TLT are currently advising clients on these issues. If you would like advice in relation to any of the above, please contact Craig Thompson or Julien Luke, partners in our Commercial Dispute Resolution team.
This publication is intended for general guidance and represents our understanding of the relevant law and practice as at September 2020. Specific advice should be sought for specific cases. For more information see our terms & conditions.
Professional negligence update webinarRead more
Data protection, fraud and cybersecurity update webinarRead more
The disputes landscape in England & Wales post Covid webinarRead more
The future of disputes and litigation in Northern Ireland webinarRead more
Council tax valuations and affordable housingRead more
Service out: helpful rulings for claims involving international...Read more
TLT wins significant result in US$22m recoveries case for Punjab...Read more
Financial services investigations and enforcement round-up - July 2020Read more
TLT expands UK-wide litigation and restructuring and insolvency teamsRead more
Green finance is gaining speed, driven by global climate change pressures and the recognition of the vital role which sustainability plays in a resilient financial services sector.Read more
Keep on top of the employment law issues that matter most to you and your business with our new podcast.Read more
As businesses adjust to new ways of working and plan for an uncertain future, we keep track of the emerging legal and regulatory issues.Read more
Keeping you up to date with the latest guidance on regulatory change and legal impact of the coronavirus pandemic.Read more
While future trading relationship with the EU is negotiated, we will be in a 'status quo' transition period until 31 December 2020. Follow our latest updates.Read more
Our Senior Managers Regime hot topic features news and insight to help banks, building societies, investment firms and UK branches of foreign banks prepare for the new regime.Read more
The clock is ticking for firms to prepare for moving from LIBOR to sterling risk-free rates. Follow our insights and events for strategic advice.Read more
We approach a brave new world of Gigabit full-fibre fixed communications, 5G mobile technologies, data driven markets enabled by true AI, with the potential for huge commercial and social growth and benefits. Follow our...Read more
Open Banking is driving innovation in banking and customer experience but also presents new challenges around security and data protection.Read more
Advising on complex and reputationally sensitive matters involving litigation, arbitration, mediation and debt recovery.Read more
Our team provide practical, commercial solutions ranging from advice in the first stages of a disagreement through to court proceedings and enforcement.Read more